Winston's Persuasive Speech

Samuel Becker

English – Period 2

Nov. 4, 2013

Time to Unite

            Hello friends, my name is Winston Smith. I am a thirty-nine year old man with medical problems and a harmful drinking habit, and today I have an urgent message for you. Big Brother does not represent you and does not care about you. I, being a loyal party member for many years, know that they don’t. I work in the Ministry of Truth, and on a daily basis I distort, censor, and erase that truth. Big Brother doesn’t want you Proles to know that you are being used as mere serfs in a plan to gain complete power over all of Oceania. They view you as inferior, and only let you have the freedom that you have because they see you as benign and unable to rise up. They control all the economic resources and create all the laws, and they leave no way for another party to democratically win over the power.

            The common man controls the numbers; they simply do not yet possess the awareness that they are being treated as a commodity nor realize that they don’t have to be used in such a manner. If you unite as one conscious body of protesters you could overthrow the dictatorship that overshadows your every move. You could live free from the bondage of oppression and illusion.

            We work day in and day out, but to what end? We get nowhere, we gain nothing, and we learn nothing. We make no difference; we have no say in the bigger picture. We aren't allow to marry for love only for procreation to add members to The Party. We aren't allow to think thoughts that go outside the tight constrictions place by Big Brother, to strengthen our faith in IngSoc. Why can’t we give ourselves a voice in society? If we gather as force, I believe we can.

            Why should the 1% possess 99% of the wealth and power? Even though they act like they distribute fairly, they only distribute evenly among you all. They keep most of the money and the control for themselves. They make laws that allow them to get away with their malevolence and prevent people from speaking out against it. Why should we tolerate this?

            They treat us as sub-human, unworthy of attention or care. They constrict our growth, our independence and our individuality. This is simply intolerable. We must wake up and see that our minds are chained, and they have programmed us for complacency. We do not have to accept these conditions, and we owe it to our descendants to create a better society before it is too late, and we have passed the point of no return, where our thoughts are not even our own.

            I fervently plead with you, Proles, to take a stand against Big Brother. If we march against them, they can’t stop us. Only we can stop us, and by not taking action we are stopping ourselves. If they provoke, we provoke, if they fight, we fight, if they call for peace, we call for peace. But no more of the fantasy and illusion of peace. The Proles deserve much better, and it is in your grasp. 

1984 Summary: Chapters 1 - 4

       1984 Summary: Chapters 1 - 4 

          Winston, the protagonist of George Orwell's 1984, is a 39 year old man of small frame with fair hair. He has an ulcer above his ankle which makes it hard for him to even climb a flight of stairs. He works for The Ministry of Truth, an organization which is part of Big Brother. He is a self-conscious being, which is something that Big Brother wouldn't approve of. He knows to wear a face of quiet optimism. His living conditions are grim; he often faces severe hunger, which he fights off by drinking Gin.


         The Party is the only political group that exists in Oceania, and they rule by manipulating the people through fear, censorship, and making their citizens ignorant to reality. The poster on the left demonstrates their sly suggestion to the people that they are omnipresent. The telescreen, an oblong box which can never be turned off completely and receives and transmits information simultaneously is their primary spying device. The people are aware of its existence and it subsequently discourages any private behavior which might displease The Party.

      The children of Oceania act as another surveillance utility for the party. This causes fear in the older generation, and even the parents of the children. Winston begins to keep a diary, in order to prevent past events from becoming blurred. He experiences anxiety because the consequences for possessing a diary are grave.

        During a daily formality known as the two minutes hate, Winston catches a glance from a man named O'Brien, which he interprets as a moment of strong connection. Winston is displeased with the current circumstances in Oceania, and he despises the party secretly, and he imagined that O'Brien's glance meant he shared the same feelings.

       Winston dreams often. He sees O'Brien, who whispers cryptic messages like, "we will meet in a place where there is no darkness". He also sees his mother in a dream, as well as a nude female figure. He usually visits a location in his dreams he calls "Golden Country" when he is awake. The dreams seem to offer a momentary escape from his worldly pain, and they take him to a state of freedom and peace.

        In the Ministry of Truth, where Winston works, the faculty are engage in record keeping, data collecting, and story making. They seem not to care whether or not they relay information accurately, and sometimes they seem to even enjoy making up fictitious stories and are encouraged to do so. Winston marvels at the fact that he can have an idea of a non real person, "create" him through writing, and then have this person acknowledged as a bona fide individual.

       The first four chapters are very eerie, and have an odd resemblance to what is taking place currently through modern technology. Orwell seemed to have precognitive abilities, in being able to so precisely predict what "Big Brother" would be able to do. Although the political systems of Orwell's time such as communist society could have inspired some of what Orwell wrote, one can still be amazed by his clairvoyance.

Citations:

"Plot Summary: Nineteen Eighty-four." EXPLORING Novels. Detroit: Gale, 2003.Student Resources In 

        Context. Web. 23 Oct. 2013.

Test, George A. "Karel Capek's `War with the Newts': A Neglected Modern Satire."DISCovering                 
        Authors. Detroit: Gale, 2003. Student Resources In Context. Web. 23 Oct. 2013.

InfraGard

                                                 InfraGard

           InfraGard is an information gathering and facilitating FBI program, which was founded in 1996. Their goal is to prevent hostile acts against the United States and its citizens by letting other agencies utilize their scavenged intelligence. It contains over 50,000 members nationwide, who's goals are to protect the national infrastructure such as drinking water, agricultural resources, and communication systems. It is assumed that the federal government alone cannot provide need protection.
         Some skeptics regard the nature of this organization as controversial because they feel that it infringes on civil liberties. The ACLU stated that they are concerned that InfraGard turns private-sector businesses into "eyes and ears of the FBI". The chairwoman of the InfraGard board of directors strongly disagrees, noting that InfraGard is available to every American.
         I hadn't heard of InfraGard before this last week. While the idea itself isn't intrinsically a harmful one, there definitely exists the potential for abuse. For example, people's private information may be collected when they wish that it remains under the radar. This information may range from anything between internet and phone records to medical and banking records. If any American is potentially able to access this information, there is virtually no way to get every single one to act responsibly with it. Of course people will use it for personal gains.
     
          As seem by the map to the left, InfraGard is a well organized system with 6 geographic regions, each with its unique issues. Although managed at the regional level, InfraGard is branded at the national level with patriotic seals. The image
that InfraGard projects is official, vs. non-profit, which it really is. It would be unwise for us to fall for their persuasive imagery and rhetoric, and believe they are sponsored by the government when they really are not. We should weigh the values of both privacy and safety on the scale of justice and make an informed decision on the value of InfraGard. The public should certainly be aware that an organization like this exists, and I will take personal responsibility for getting the word out.

Sources: https://www.infragard.org, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/InfraGard, http://www.fbi.gov/news/stories/2010/march/infragard_030810